Standup vs Open vs Closed MRI Machines

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an imaging procedure that uses magnetism, radio frequencies, and a computer to produce detailed images of organs and structures within the body. It’s important to note that MRIs do not use radiation, unlike CT scans or X-Rays.

MRI machines come in 3 main configurations:

• 1) Closed
• 2) Standup
• 3) Open

Below we will explore each of the three configurations along with their benefits and drawbacks.

What is a Closed MRI?

A closed MRI machine is a cylinder-like space where the patient lies in to have the scan done. These machines typically have very strong magnets (ranging from 0.3 to 3.0 Tesla) and this allows them to produce highly detailed, high-quality images. The only drawback is they require the patient to remain completely still during the duration of the scan. For this reason, they are not always the best option for children, and for patients with claustrophobia or anxiety.

What is a Standup MRI?

A standup MRI scanner, as the name implies, allows patients to be scanned in any position, including standing, sitting, bending or lying down.

It can position the patient for the full range of conventional “lie-down” MRI scans done in closed machines. Additionally, it is the only MRI capable of scanning patients in positions where they carry their own weight. This can help detect problems that would be underestimated or unnoticed by conventional MRI machines.

What is an Open MRI?

Open MRI machines differ from closed in the way that patients are not surrounded on all sides. Magnets are positioned on the top and the bottom with a large open space in the middle for the patient to lay in. For this reason, open MRI machines are a great fit for patients with claustrophobia or anxiety, as well as for children, who usually have a hard time remaining still.

These machines have less powerful magnets compared to traditional closed machines (ranging from 0.2T – 1.2T). However, the benefits for the patient often outweigh this limitation primarily because of their ease and increased patient comfort level.

Tips for getting the best price for an MRI scan

• Ask a doctor for the MRI referral to take with you
• Ensure your doctor lists what type of scan is needed. i.e contrast vs no contrast
• Use a concierge service to help narrow down facilities in your area
• Offer to pay cash – cash patients get the lowest prices

Not sure where to start?

See how much you can save >Our concierge will help you find the most affordable imaging center near you.